Sales on Sanibel & Captiva Island | McMurray and Members

SWFL Real Estate: Record-Breaking Sales on Sanibel & Captiva Island

Here at McMurray & Members of Royal Shell Real Estate, we are very excited to celebrate many major record-breaking sales over the past few months.

With five record sales at a combined $27.45 million, our real estate team continues to be top listing and sales producers for Sanibel, Captiva Island and the greater Southwest Florida area.

From a historic listing on Sanibel’s Woodring Point to prime waterfront real estate on Southwest Florida’s Gulf beaches, get ready to hear about some of our greatest real estate successes as of late.

Record-Breaking Sales on Sanibel & Captiva Island After Hurricane Ian

With the ongoing endeavor of rebuilding our island communities after the impact of Hurricane Ian, Sanibel & Captiva Island real estate is still holding its value and selling quickly.

In fact, the properties below broke records for their sale prices and the speed at which they sold.

Keep reading to see what recently sold for record numbers on our beloved barrier islands.

Waterfront Property With Historical Significance on Sanibel Island

Largest Recorded Home Sale on Sanibel Island Bayside

Originally the site of a fishing club and boarding house that were active during the turn of the century, this is an iconic piece of Southwest Florida waterfront real estate. The spacious Sanibel Island estate boasts 10,000 square feet of indoor-outdoor living, and the property itself sits on 1.5 acres of prime Sanibel real estate.

Location: 1800 Woodring Road

Sale price: $7,250,000

Closed: 01/21/2023

Represented: Seller

Beachfront Gulf-Facing Estate on Sanibel Island

This timeless island estate sits right on the Gulf of Mexico with sweeping views of the beachfront. Located on a premier stretch of Sanibel’s West Gulf Drive, this property offers world renowned shelling right from the owner’s backyard. McMurray & Members is proud to represent both the buyer and seller in this monumental sale.

Location: 3657 West Gulf Drive

Sale price: $4,500,000

Closed: 12/12/2022

Represented: Buyer & Seller

Oversized Beachfront Property on the Gold Coast of Captiva

As one of the largest properties on Captiva Island’s premium stretch, this Gold Coast property presents 185 feet of beachfront. With a 2+ acre lot and a spacious & charming beach cottage, this is a quintessential piece of Captiva Island real estate.

Location: 16778 Captiva Drive

Sale Price: $6,950,000

Closed: 01/10/2023

Represented: Buyer

Luxurious Sanibel Island Beachfront Estate

Largest Ever Recorded Home Sale on Sanibel Island

With breathtaking panoramic views of the Gulf of Mexico, this impressive beachfront estate is unlike all others. Offering 300 feet of sandy shoreline, it’s rare to find such an expansive slice of paradise. Inside and out, the estate boasts all the features that say luxury at every turn. It’s no wonder this was the largest ever recorded sale on Sanibel Island!

Location: 3845 West Gulf Drive

Sale Price: $11,700,000

Closed: 11/30/2022

Represented: Seller

1.5 Acre Lot on the Gulf of Mexico

Located on a high ridge with an ideal coastal control line, this Sanibel property is incredibly private while offering unobstructed panoramic views of the Gulf. With over an acre of land, the premium beachfront lot is a rare find on our SWFL islands. Our real estate team proudly represented both parties in this record-breaking deal.

Location: 0 West Gulf Drive

Sale Price: $4,250,000

Closed: 01/10/2023

Represented: Buyer & Seller

Buy or Sell with a Top Producing SWFL Realtor

Are you ready to make your Southwest Florida real estate dreams a reality?

Whether you want to list your existing piece of paradise or find something new (or both), we are the SWFL real estate team for you.

McMurray & Members of Royal Shell Real Estate bring 30+ years of experience in buying and selling SWFL real estate. With a special focus on Sanibel & Captiva, we are your go-to for luxury listings on our islands.