Sanibel Causeway stretches across green-blue water beyond a sandy beach.

Sanibel Island Real Estate Market Report: September, 2025

Sanibel Market Reports

Sanibel Island Real Estate Market Update – September, 2025 Home Prices & Trends

MARKET SUMMARY

Sanibel Island | September, 2025 | ALL PROPERTY TYPES

Sanibel Island market summary table comparing September 2025 and 2024 with year-to-date figures.

NEW PROPERTIES

Number of new properties listed for sale during the month

Chart of monthly new listings and four-month moving average, October 2022–September 2025.

AVERAGE SALES PRICE

Average price for sold properties (6-Month Moving Average)

Line chart of average sold prices, October 2022–September 2025, mostly ranging from $1.1 million to $1.4 million.

AVERAGE SALES/LIST PRICE

Average list price compared to average sold price of properties sold each month (6-Month Moving Average)

Sanibel Island average sold and list prices, October 2022–September 2025.

AVERAGE ASKING/SOLD/UNSOLD PRICE

Asking Price | the average asking price of sold properties
Sold Price | the average selling price
Unsold Price | the average active list price

Line chart comparing Sanibel Island asking, sold, and unsold average prices from October 2022 to September 2025.

PROPERTIES FOR SALE

Number of properties currently listed for sale by price range

Bar chart of property counts by price range, highest in the $1.5M+ range.

AVERAGE SALES PRICE PER SQFT

Average Sales Price per SqFt for previous two years

Bar chart comparing price per square foot across home price ranges for two recent periods.

MONTHS SUPPLY OF INVENTORY

Properties for sale divided by number of properties sold

Sanibel Island inventory chart from October 2022 to September 2025, with gray bars and a blue four-month moving average line.

AVERAGE SALES PRICE AND AVERAGE DAYS ON MARKET

Average Sales Price | Average sales price for all properties sold.
Average Days on Market | Average days on market for all properties sold.

Sanibel Island market chart showing average sales prices and days on market from October 2022 to September 2025.

MONTHS SUPPLY OF INVENTORY

Months Supply of Inventory | Properties for sale divided by number of properties sold.
Units Listed | Number of properties listed for sale at the end of month.
Units Sold | Number of properties sold.

Sanibel Island market chart showing units listed, units sold, and inventory above or below five months.

 

Recent Blog Posts

Elevated white stucco house with a metal roof, glazed balcony, concrete support columns and a pale driveway beside coastal planting.
Why Fort Myers Beach's Houses Are Coming Back Faster Than Its Hotels
Sunlit elevated lanai with pale tile, white stucco, closed glass doors, a weathered teak bench and silver thatch palm beyond the parapet.
Why Fort Myers Beach's Fall Starts at the South End This Year
Sunlit condominium balcony with white stucco, closed glass doors, limestone paving, a teak-armed lounge chair and a container-grown fan palm.
Downtown Fort Myers Reopens to Boats From the West End First
Closed bronze-framed glass entry door beside warm-white stucco, limestone paving, and a planter with a palm and cycads.
Cape Coral's Restaurants Didn't Get the Memo About September
Hands exchange house keys over a property document beside a calculator.
Understanding Real Estate Contingencies and How They Work

A Clear Guide to Real Estate Contingencies for Fort Myers Buyers and Sellers.

Woman in a hard hat checks a ceiling while holding an architectural plan.
The Home Inspection Process Explained for Fort Myers Buyers

A Clear Guide to the Home Inspection Process for Fort Myers Buyers.

Open suitcase packed with yellow sneakers, hats, and sunglasses on a bed.
The Ultimate Guide to Weekend Fun Near Fort Myers

Your Ultimate Guide to Weekend Fun Near Fort Myers, Florida.

Waterfront pool terrace with gray pavers, a palm, native grasses, and a weathered dock extending toward mangrove-lined water.
Why Captiva's Loudest Week Is Also Its Quietest
A red SOLD sign in front of a softly blurred modern two-story house.
How to Make a Winning Offer in a Competitive Market

Smart Strategies for a Winning Offer in a Competitive Market.

View All

Thinking Real Estate

You will appreciate working with a team who is more like an extended family, one that takes care of each other and encourages success. Plus, we are backed by the strength of Royal Shell.

Let's Talk

Follow Us On Instagram
Get in Touch
Contact Details

McMurray and Members of Royal Shell Real Estate

 

(239) 356-6836

[email protected]

7290 College Pkwy Ste 102
Fort Myers FL 33907

 

959 Periwinkle Way

Sanibel FL 33957