Ocean sunset framed by silhouetted palm trees and beach grass.

Captiva Island Real Estate Market Report: September, 2025

Captiva Island Market Reports Mike McMurray - Top real estate agent SWFL

Captiva Island Real Estate Market Update – September, 2025 Home Prices & Trends

MARKET SUMMARY

Captiva Island | September, 2025 | ALL PROPERTY TYPES

Captiva Island market report table comparing September and year-to-date real estate statistics for 2025 and 2024.

NEW PROPERTIES

Number of new properties listed for sale during the month

Captiva Island new listings chart, with a blue four-month moving average peaking in early 2025.

AVERAGE SALES PRICE

Average price for sold properties (6-Month Moving Average)

Sold prices chart from October 2022 to September 2025, with average prices ranging from $0M to $4.5M.

AVERAGE SALES/LIST PRICE

Average list price compared to average sold price of properties sold each month (6-Month Moving Average)

Chart comparing average sold and list prices from October 2022 to September 2025.

AVERAGE ASKING/SOLD/UNSOLD PRICE

Asking Price | the average asking price of sold properties
Sold Price | the average selling price
Unsold Price | the average active list price

Chart comparing Captiva Island asking, sold, and unsold average prices from October 2022 to September 2025.

PROPERTIES FOR SALE

Number of properties currently listed for sale by price range

Bar chart showing property counts across eight Captiva Island price ranges, led by $0–1M and $1–2M.

AVERAGE SALES PRICE PER SQFT

Average Sales Price per SqFt for previous two years

Captiva Island real estate price-per-square-foot chart comparing two periods across home price ranges.

MONTHS SUPPLY OF INVENTORY

Properties for sale divided by number of properties sold

Captiva Island inventory and four-month moving average chart, October 2022 to September 2025.

AVERAGE SALES PRICE AND AVERAGE DAYS ON MARKET

Average Sales Price | Average sales price for all properties sold.
Average Days on Market | Average days on market for all properties sold.

Chart comparing average days on market and average sales price from Oct 2022 to Sep 2025.

MONTHS SUPPLY OF INVENTORY

Months Supply of Inventory | Properties for sale divided by number of properties sold.
Units Listed | Number of properties listed for sale at the end of month.
Units Sold | Number of properties sold.

Captiva Island market chart of units listed, units sold, and months of inventory from October 2022 to September 2025.

 

Thinking Real Estate

You will appreciate working with a team who is more like an extended family, one that takes care of each other and encourages success. Plus, we are backed by the strength of Royal Shell.

Follow Us On Instagram